Learning and Maturity In The Church

Christian maturity involves a complex interplay of experiential and fundamental learning. This article explores how these two learning approaches contribute to personal growth, the various ways churches implement these strategies, and the importance of reflecting on these methods to foster mutual respect and understanding within the Christian community.

The Nature of Maturity

Maturity encompasses a deepening understanding and integration of knowledge and experiences. It involves a transformation in one's character and behavior, reflecting a more advanced level of cognitive and emotional development. This maturation process can be analyzed through psychological principles related to learning and development.

Learning and Maturity

Experiential Learning

Experiential learning is a process through which individuals gain knowledge and skills from direct experiences. This learning style emphasizes practical application and reflection on personal encounters.

1. Real-Life Application: Experiential learning involves applying theoretical knowledge to real-life situations. This approach helps individuals test and refine their understanding through practice, leading to a more nuanced and contextually relevant grasp of concepts.

2. Adaptation and Growth: As individuals engage in various experiences, they adapt and modify their understanding based on feedback. This iterative process supports continuous growth and the development of more sophisticated cognitive and emotional skills.

3. Potential Challenges: While experiential learning promotes personal insight, it may lead to inconsistencies if not supported by a solid theoretical foundation. Without a structured framework, individuals might encounter conflicting interpretations or misapplications of knowledge.

Fundamental Learning

Fundamental learning focuses on acquiring core knowledge and principles. This method provides a structured approach to understanding key concepts, which can guide and support experiential learning.

1. Structured Understanding: Fundamental learning offers a systematic approach to grasping essential principles. It provides a coherent framework that helps individuals organize and integrate new information effectively.

2. Guidance and Consistency: A robust foundation in fundamental principles ensures consistency in understanding. It serves as a reference point for interpreting experiences and making informed decisions.

3. Potential Challenges: While fundamental learning provides essential knowledge, it may lack practical application. Individuals may struggle to connect theoretical concepts with real-life situations if opportunities for experiential learning are limited.

Combining Experiential and Fundamental Learning: A Life Perspective

Understanding how experiential and fundamental learning apply in life can be illustrated through several relatable scenarios.

Scenario 1: Dropping Out to "Get On With Life"
Consider someone who leaves school early, driven by the desire to "get on with life." Initially, their practical, real-world experiences allow them to gain some ground, but without a solid foundational understanding, they struggle as life becomes more complex. Their ability to adapt and progress is limited because they lack the broader knowledge needed to make sense of new challenges and opportunities. As the world around them grows more demanding, they find themselves increasingly outpaced, unable to keep up with the changes that require more than just experience—they need a comprehensive foundation.

Scenario 2: Completing High School but Stopping There
Now imagine someone who completes high school, gaining a foundational understanding but choosing not to pursue further formal education. They enter the workforce with a decent base of knowledge, and while they manage well initially, their growth eventually plateaus. The lack of further foundational learning makes it harder for them to integrate new, more complex experiences, leaving them well-equipped for routine tasks but less prepared for unexpected challenges or advancements that require deeper knowledge and broader skills.

Scenario 3: College Graduate Focused Solely on Study
Next, consider a college graduate who focuses heavily on their studies but neglects to gain practical experience. They possess a thorough understanding of their field's fundamentals, but when they step into the real world, they struggle to apply their knowledge effectively. Without the practical experiences to contextualize and reinforce their learning, their understanding remains largely theoretical, and they may find themselves overwhelmed by the gap between what they know and what they can actually do.

Scenario 4: College Graduate Who Balances Study and Experience
Finally, picture a college graduate who not only builds a strong foundation through their studies but also actively seeks out practical experiences, such as internships, projects, or part-time work. This individual is well-prepared to enter the workforce, capable of applying their knowledge in a variety of contexts. The combination of a complete foundational understanding and broad experiences enables them to adapt, innovate, and excel in their field, making them highly effective and versatile in a progressively demanding world.

The Power of Combining Fundamentals and Experience

These scenarios highlight a critical truth: while experience is valuable, its power is maximized when grounded in a solid foundation. Individuals who start with complete fundamentals and build on them with broad experiences are best equipped to thrive in any environment. Conversely, those who rely solely on experience without a strong foundational understanding may struggle to integrate new information and adapt to complex situations.

The Graphic: Visualizing the Intersection of Learning

The following graphic visualizes the interplay between two critical dimensions of learning: Experience (X-axis) and Fundamentals (Y-axis). The X-axis spans from Narrow Experiences on the left, representing limited exposure to real-world scenarios, to Broad Experiences on the right, signifying a wide range of practical encounters that enrich understanding. The Y-axis ranges from Incomplete Fundamentals at the bottom, indicating a lack of comprehensive foundational knowledge, to Complete Fundamentals at the top, representing a thorough grasp of core principles.

In the Lower Left (LL) Natural quadrant, individuals begin with narrow experiences and incomplete fundamentals, often learning through trial and error. While they may gradually build a foundation from these experiences, the process is slow and marked by numerous setbacks, which significantly stunts their growth and pace. Moving to the Lower Right (LR) Experienced quadrant, individuals with broader experiences but incomplete fundamentals find themselves better equipped to handle diverse situations, but their lack of a solid foundational understanding still limits their long-term growth. 

Those in the Upper Left (UL) Grounded quadrant possess more complete fundamentals but have narrow experiences, akin to individuals who have focused heavily on academic learning without applying it practically. They have a strong theoretical foundation but may struggle to adapt their knowledge to real-world situations. Finally, the Upper Right (UR) Ideal quadrant represents those who combine broad experiences with a more complete foundation. These individuals are best positioned for success, as their deep understanding and practical insights allow them to adapt quickly and excel in complex environments.

Natural Learning vs. Complete Fundamentals

This graphic also illustrates the distinction between natural learning processes and the potential for complete fundamentals in human development. In the animal kingdom, learning is a natural process that evolves slowly over centuries. Animals rely on instinct and gradual adaptation, represented by the Natural arrow moving from "Experienced" to "Ideal." This progression is slow and often limited by the environment and experiences available to them on the way to the ideal.

In contrast, humans have the unique ability to rapidly develop a comprehensive understanding by establishing a more Complete foundation early in life. The Complete arrow, moving from "Grounded" to "Ideal," represents the accelerated learning path that humans can achieve. By starting with a solid theoretical framework and building on it with broad experiences, humans can accomplish in decades what might take animals millennia. This accelerated development underscores the importance of prioritizing a complete foundation to fully leverage the potential of broad experiences.

Application to Churches

Recognizing the power of combining complete fundamentals with broad experiences has significant implications for how churches approach teaching and spiritual growth. Just as individuals benefit from a solid foundation and varied experiences, churches that emphasize comprehensive theological teaching and encourage practical application can foster deeper, more adaptable spiritual maturity among their members.

To understand how different churches implement these principles, we can categorize their approaches:

Reflection and Respect in the Body of Christ

This table illustrates the diverse ways in which churches approach theological education and spiritual growth. Each category reflects different methods of combining foundational teaching with experiential learning, all aiming to help believers mature in their faith. Some churches prioritize comprehensive theological foundations, others focus on gradual learning to ease new believers into deeper understanding, and some allow individuals the freedom to explore at their own pace or adapt to contemporary contexts.

Rather than viewing these approaches as competing, it’s important to see how they can complement each other within the body of Christ. Churches that emphasize gradual theology can play a crucial role in attracting new believers, providing them with the essential building blocks of faith. As these individuals grow, churches offering a more complete theology can help them deepen their understanding and commitment, fostering a more profound and resilient faith. Similarly, focused theology provides a space for exploration, and adaptive theology helps the church remain relevant and engaging in a changing world.

By reflecting on these diverse approaches and respecting the role each church plays, we can appreciate how they work together to strengthen the broader Christian community. Each method contributes uniquely to the mission of glorifying God and helping believers grow in their faith.

YOUR COMMENTS ARE IMPORTANT!!!

Postscript: The Inspiration Behind This Article

The inspiration for this article came from a discussion about Dominion and Relational Theology and the recognition of the essential nature of Relational Theology relative to the more complete theology of Dominion. If you are not familiar with them, Relational Theology focuses on the nature of our personal relationship with God, and for many, that is the essential aspect of faith. Dominion Theology, however, builds on this by recognizing not only the importance of a relationship with God but also the mandate to be fruitful, multiply, and exercise dominion over God's creation for His glory and our enjoyment of Him. While Dominion is impossible without a solid relationship with God, the question arises: do we stop there? 

Incorporating both theological perspectives is more challenging, but it's also more relevant, considering that Dominion Theology applies to everything we do here on earth. It's seems like Relational Theology is to reading what Relational Theology is to learning the alphabet--it's impossible to read without recognizing and using letters. But if we stop at learning our letters, are we complete in God's eyes? This also underscores how much easier it would be for believers to recognize that everything they do is for the glory of God, not just their personal relationship with Him. By embracing both relational and dominion aspects, believers can grow into a more complete understanding of their faith and their role in God's creation...and perhaps a more complete foundation.